If you go to a comedy show in New York City, especially in Brooklyn, you are bound to hear somewhere in the range of 5-15 gentrification jokes. For someone a whole bunch of decades old, who was born and raised in the Big Apple, it is a bit hard to stomach jokes about how the city has changed told by a recent transplant from Atlanta, Wisconsin, or even New Jersey. Only a real New Yorker should be allowed to share their perspective to a large audience on how the city has changed over time. Yet…
How do you know if someone is a REAL New Yorker?
Some people say you have to have lived in New York for at least seven years to earn the “Real New Yorker” title. It should be at least eight. One cannot forget the significance of the seven year itch. The idea there is happiness in a relationship tends to decline after seven years, leading to wandering eyes and relationship implosion. If you can hold on through the tumult or boredom of the seventh year, you just might make it for the long run.
A relationship with New York is just as, if not more, intense than a relationship with a significant other. If you can’t push through that seventh year of long winters, humid summers, angry rush hour commuters, bike thievery, impressive traffic, lines galore, customer service that makes the name seem like an oxymoron, and overpriced… everything, you may not be meant for NYC.
Just to clarify, “real New Yorkers” are defined here as “legitimate inhabitants of New York City”, as opposed to “legitimate inhabitants of New York State”. Geographically speaking, the city is a region found within the state, but a distinction between the two is crucial for just about all other purposes. If you believe them to be one and the same, then either you have never been to the likes of the outskirts of Buffalo or you have never been to the likes of the heart of the Bronx. Either way, you are not a real New Yorker.
And if I need to tell you that, when I write New York, I am referring to the five boroughs (kinda… I’m not really thinking about Staten Island… maybe just the part right near the ferry), then you are definitely not a real New Yorker.
Others have said that real New Yorkers use public transportation without ever looking at maps or apps. Eh… if that is your situation, you rarely stray from your route to the coffee shop (where you are a barista or you are writing a novel while flirting with the barista) to your apartment. Real New Yorkers know that subway routes change often enough that maps and apps are quite helpful (especially the Weekender), just in case the 1, 9 or double R make a comeback, or something local decides to go express, halfway up Manhattan or halfway across Queens, in one stop.
Some believe they are REAL New Yorkers because they explore different neighborhoods each weekend, with the goal of seeing the whole city. Well, a real New Yorker knows: the city is massive. It is impossible to see every corner of it… So why try? Exploring, by definition, is done in places that are not your home.
And, while Real New Yorkers may fight it tooth and nail, New York City is their home. Even if they leave it for long amounts of time, it is their base… their reference point… their internal compass. It is the place they love to hate, hate to love, love to love, and hate to hate… all within about 5 minutes time. That is the definition of home, isn’t it?
And when I say they explore different neighborhoods, the chances of them driving there are slim, unless they are over the age of 25. Because a real New Yorker doesn’t get their driver’s license at 16… or 17… or 18… or… Driving is not a rite of passage. Taking public transportation unchaperoned is.
A real New Yorker knows they are not among their brethren when they tell someone they were born and raised in New York, and the response is, “Oh, really? You are from here? I don’t think I have ever met anyone actually from here before! All of my friends have moved here from somewhere else! That is SO cool.” There is an easy explanation for why these people have not met others born and raised in New York. Real New Yorkers don’t hang out with the likes of them.
No offense intended! Just sayin’, real New Yorkers have family close by, and friends they met back when kids played in the street. Yes, kids PLAYED IN THE STREET. All the time! Not a nanny in sight. And it wasn’t a safer time… quite the contrary. The way to make a community safe is not by hiding inside, but by chilling outside. Make your presence known, in high numbers, and no one will bother you. You have something to be afraid of when you let someone else smell your fear. Real New Yorkers know the key to avoiding being a target.
And there is nothing all that special about being born and raised in New York City. There are millions of people that share that title. How is being one in a whole lotta millions a special thing? Try being from Monowi, Nebraska, population count: one. Now that person is special!
But then, does a real New Yorker have to have been born and raised in New York? Not necessarily. There are plenty of people who have moved to New York at a young age, or even a not so young age, and embody it with full gusto.
They can drive around without using a navigation device every time, and they understand the ins and outs of alternate side of the street parking.
A handful of Yiddish words have worked their way into their vocabulary, whether they are Jewish or not, and whether they realize it or not. And they know the difference between tostones and maduros – at least by sight.
They know that the price of a slice of pizza roughly correlates to the price of one ride on public transport. If it is much more expensive, it isn’t worth the extra cash. And if it is much cheaper, it isn’t worth the awful flavor.
The time has come to put all this banter aside and admit:
There is a sure fire way to know if someone is a real New Yorker.
It has nothing to do with where they were born, how long they have lived in the city, how they move around it, or even how much they love it, or hate it, or love to hate it.
A real New Yorker could care less about whether or not anybody else thinks they are a real New Yorker.
They know they are.









Pensando bem, ser Ms. Ruby é melhor que ser Ms. Shits? Sim. Mas ser Ms. Abusada é melhor que ser Ms. Merda? Jamais. 






Cuando vi esos ojos por la primera vez, ya sabía, inmediatamente, que me había metido en problemas. No sabía la naturaleza de ellos, pero reconocía la sensación. La había tenido antes, de adolescente, cuando esperaba mi turno para subir una montaña rusa, The Blue Streak, con mi prima allí en el parque de Conneaut Lake. Quedaba cerca del pueblito donde creció mi papá.